Pizza has become a staple food for many people, especially during vacations.
Nothing beats the feeling of indulging in a hot and cheesy slice of pizza after a long day of exploring new places and experiences. From traditional Neapolitan-style pies to unique creations with local flavors, you’ll find something to satisfy your pizza cravings on Hilton Head. So where exactly should you head to for the best pizza experience? Keep reading to find out.
Jake’s Pizza at the Salty Dog Cafe
Salty Dog Cafe is a must-visit spot for any pizza lover. Located in South Beach Marina Village in Sea Pines Resort, this restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with stunning views of the marina. Their wood-fired pizzas are made with fresh, local ingredients and unique toppings like shrimp, barbecue chicken, and roasted vegetables. Learn More about Jake’s Pizza.
Top Dawg Tavern & Pizzeria
Grab a slice of heaven at Top Dawg Tavern & Pizzeria in Shelter Cove Harbour & Marina! With pizzas like their Cheese Please!, Pepperoni Explosion, Rajun Cajun, Carne Amorem, the Aloha and Prime Time, there is a pie for every preference. Learn More about Top Dawg.
Big Jim’s BBQ, Burgers, Pizza & Catering
This eatery, located at the Robert Trent Jones Golf Course in Palmetto Dunes, offers pizza, drinks & more. From your basic cheese pizza for the purist to the amazing Buffalo Chicken Pizza, boasting Buffalo Ranch sauce, mozzarella and fried chicken, your palate is sure to be pleased. For a pie with a true Italian experience, we recommend the Caprese Pizza with an olive oil & garlic base, mozzarella, spinach, Roma tomatoes, and balsamic glaze. Learn More about Big Jim’s.
Dough Boys
Dough Boys’ pizza is crafted using organic spring wheat flour from Vermont, authentic San Marzano tomatoes from Italy for the sauce, fresh Wisconsin cheese, and extra virgin olive oil imported from Greece. They source all our produce from the South Carolina Farmers Market, prioritizing local ingredients whenever they are in season. For the pepperoni lover, try the Boardwalk with extra cheese, two layers of pepperoni, and red sauce. And for those who cheer cheese, opt for Spring Brake Jake, with Mozzarella, provolone, parmesan, romano and the house blend. Learn More about Dough Boys.
Local Pie Hilton Head
Local Pie’s wood-fired pizza ovens reach blazing temperatures of over 800 degrees, ensuring perfectly crispy dough with just the right touch of char. It’s their take on the traditional Neapolitan style, featuring light toppings and a perfectly balanced sauce. Prefer your pie to be less crispy? Just let them know when you order. Learn More about Local Pie.
Frosty Frog Cafe
Known as the “The Frostiest Place on Hilton Head Island” for its legendary daiquiris, the pizza at the Frosty Frog is famous, as well. We recommend Greg’s White Pizza, named after longtime local, Greg White. It’s a build-your-own pie, using an olive oil and minced garlic base. Then you can pile on the toppings of your choice. Learn More about the Frosty Frog.
Bella Italia Pizza
A community favorite, Bella Italia Pizza has proudly served as a trusted Slice partner for 12 years. Bella Italia’s pizzas start with a homemade, hand-spun, hearth-baked New York-style crust. We suggest the Margherita Thin with olive oil blended with garlic and herbs, served with tomatoes and fresh basil. Learn More about Bella Italia.
Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs
Fat Baby’s crafts as much as they can from scratch, and it shows. The homemade mozzarella is absolutely delicious, and their Greek dressing is so good they should consider bottling it! We recommend “The Fat Baby.” It’s their signature pie with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, onion, green pepper, black olive, mushroom and extra cheese. Learn More about Fat Baby’s.
Mangiamo’s
Not only is Mangiamo’s your home away from home if you’re a Buckeyes fan, but it’s also worth the trip from Ohio just for the pizza! All pizzas are prepared with their fresh Homemade dough, topped with their Homemade tomato sauce and a fine blend of Bacio part skim milk mozzarella cheese. For something out of the ordinary with a kick, try the Spicy Chicken Pizza with homemade ranch dressing, mozzarella cheese, chicken tossed in homemade buffalo sauce and bacon. Learn More about Mangiamo’s.
No matter where you go on Hilton Head Island, you’re bound to find some amazing pizza options.
Whether you prefer traditional or unique flavors, there’s something for every taste bud on the island. So next time you’re craving a slice, try one of these top-rated spots and experience the best pizza on Hilton Head Island for yourself! Keep exploring and trying new places – who knows where your next favorite pizza spot might be.
